Latest topics
» Ken O'Keefe - Can we Abolish the Federal Reserve?
Today at 1:40 am by MartyM

» POOFness for JUNE 17: A FATHER'S LOVE FROM GHOULKOWSKI THE INTERNET CON-ARTIST
Yesterday at 11:19 pm by RamblerNash

» ~ Into Dust ~
Yesterday at 10:34 pm by PurpleSkyz

» How To Make a Judge Run Out Of The Court Room, magic and curses
Yesterday at 1:00 pm by Consciousness Of Economic

» Live: ‘Free Assange’ demonstration on WikiLeaks’ founder sixth year since asylum application
Yesterday at 12:58 pm by PurpleSkyz

» Richard McDonald on State Citizenship (5/2/1998)
Yesterday at 12:35 pm by Consciousness Of Economic

» Our goal, when it comes to Jerzy Babkowski, a.k.a. ZAP
Yesterday at 12:22 pm by 4-truth

» NASA ADMITS WE NEVER WENT TO THE MOON
Yesterday at 11:55 am by PurpleSkyz

» Carrying Stones & Digging Holes Radio Show June 16, 2018
Yesterday at 11:45 am by Consciousness Of Economic

» Scientists Are Tapping Into Eerie 'Volcano Music' to Predict Future Eruptions
Yesterday at 11:34 am by PurpleSkyz

» THE ANTARCTICA STRANGENESS LIST JUST BECAME EVEN STRANGER
Yesterday at 11:31 am by PurpleSkyz

» Socialism exposed: thick lipstick on a global pig by Jon Rappoport
Yesterday at 11:28 am by PurpleSkyz

» Footage in New Zealand shows UFO threatening witness
Yesterday at 11:03 am by PurpleSkyz

» Flash floods wash away streets in Lake Linden, Michigan
Yesterday at 10:59 am by PurpleSkyz

» Ugandan Bacteria used in "Vaccine Against Depression"
Yesterday at 10:54 am by PurpleSkyz

» INSIDE FOOTAGE FREEMASON MASS MEETING & MORE
Yesterday at 10:42 am by PurpleSkyz

» This Will Leave You Speechless! - One of The Most Eye Opening Videos
Yesterday at 10:35 am by PurpleSkyz

» The occult archetype called vaccination By Jon Rappoport
Yesterday at 10:25 am by MartyM

» Ley Lines- The “KEY” to Unlocking the Matrix
Yesterday at 10:24 am by PurpleSkyz

» Kp Message 6-18-18… “Really? When I ‘voted’ for ‘The Alliance’, I signed up for THIS?”
Yesterday at 10:18 am by PurpleSkyz

» Leaked Image of Barack Obama Dressed as Satan Goes Viral??
Yesterday at 10:12 am by terbo56

» YAFTV - TRUMP: Space Force, Spy Gate, IG-FAIL, Pedo-Elites Toast #CRICKETS
Yesterday at 10:01 am by PurpleSkyz

» Trump Behind The Scenes The Critical Post Chicago Report
Yesterday at 9:59 am by PurpleSkyz

» UFO News ~ High Speed Horseshoe UFO Filmed Over France plus MORE
Yesterday at 9:54 am by PurpleSkyz

» Empty inside - Jun 17, 2018 Stonehenge crop circle
Yesterday at 9:45 am by PurpleSkyz


You are not connected. Please login or register

Out Of Mind » THE INSANITY OF REALITY » GOVERNMENT & THE NEW WORLD ORDER » Foreclosure --- Update on fraud-closure

Foreclosure --- Update on fraud-closure

Go down  Message [Page 1 of 1]

1 Foreclosure --- Update on fraud-closure on Tue Nov 06, 2012 1:26 am

ymoilman2


Foreclosure --- Update on fraud-closure
Monday, November 5, 2012

Ohio Supreme Court: Bombshell win for homeowners
BOMBSHELL WIN: Schwartzwald vs. Federal Home Loan (Freddie Mac)
Lack of standing CANNOT be cured or remedied with a later assigned mortgage
Judgement REVERSED and CASE DISMISSED


Explosive Legal News:
Supreme Court of OHIO:
Cases: Nos. 2011-1201 and 2011-1362 - Submitted April 4, 2012

Decided: October 31, 2012
Written Opinion: Judge Terrance O'Donnell
O’CONNOR, C.J., and PFEIFER, LUNDBERG STRATTON, LANZINGER, CUPP,and M

CGEE BROWN, JJ CONCUR

This is a major victory and EXPLOSIVE NEWS in the FRAUDclosure battle


Federal Home Loan Mortgage Corp. v. Duane Schwartzwald et al. (HERE)
The Supreme Court of Ohio ruled that standing to initiate a mortgage foreclosure lawsuit is determined on the date the complaint is filed. A foreclosing party, which lacked standing at the time the suit was filed, CANNOT remedy that defect by obtaining an assignment of a mortgage and promissory note AFTER the filing of the foreclosure action but prior to an entry of a final judgment.

The court’s 7-0 unanimous decision dismissed a decree of foreclosure granted to Federal Home Loan Mortgage Corporation FHLMA (AKA "Freddie Mac") against Duane and Julie Schwartzwald because FHLMA did not have standing at the time it filed the foreclosure action.

Congratulations to the court for making the right decision and for upholding the law. Many similar cases were cited from other states to support the decision. Congratulations to fine attorney ANDREW ENGEL for fighting this battle on behalf of the Schwartwald family (no longer in the home) and attorney BRUCE BROYLES for submitting an amicus brief on behalf of this blog
OHIO FRAUDCLOSUE (our amicus brief here) and OHIO homeowners

COURT FINDS:

{¶41}It is fundamental that a party commencing litigation must have standing to sue in order to invoke jurisdiction of the common pleas court. Civ.R. 17(A) does not change this principle, and a lack of standing at the outset of litigation cannot be cured by receipt of an {later post filing} assignment .... or by substitution of the real party in interest.

{¶42}Here it is undisputed that Federal Home Loan did not have standing at the time it commenced this foreclosure action, and therefore it failed... Accordingly, the judgment of the court of appeals is reversed, and the cause is dismissed.

OTHER STATE DECISIONS were relied upon:
{¶27}This principle accords with decisions from other states holding that standing is determined as of the filing the complaint.

See, e.g., Deutsche Bank Natl. Trust v. Brumbaugh, 2012 OK 3, 270 P.3d 151, ¶ 11 (“If Deutsche Bank became a person entitled to enforce the note as either a holder or nonholder in possession who has the rights of a holder after the foreclosure action was filed, then the case may be dismissed without prejudice * * *” [emphasis added]);
U.S.Bank Natl. Assn. v. Kimball, 190 Vt. 210, 2011 VT 81, 27 A.3d 1087, ¶ 14 (“U.S. Bank was required to show that at the time the complaint was filed it possessed the original note either made payable to bearer with a blank endorsement or made payable to order with an endorsement specifically to U.S. Bank” [emphasis added]);
Mtge. Electronic Registration Sys., Inc. v. Saunders, 2010 ME 79, 2 A.3d 287, ¶ 15 (“Without possession of or any interest in the note, MERS lacked standing to institute foreclosure proceedings and could not invoke the jurisdiction of our trial courts” [emphasis added]);
RMS Residential Properties, L.L.C. v.Miller, 303 Conn. 224, 229, 232, 32 A.3d 309 (2011), quoting Hiland v. Ives, 28 Conn.Supp. 243, 245, 257 A.2d 822 (1966) (explaining that “ ‘[s]tanding is the legal right to set judicial machinery in motion’ ” and holding that the plaintiff had standing because it proved ownership of the note and mortgage at the time it commenced foreclosure action);
McLean v. JP Morgan Chase Bank Natl. Assn., 79 So.3d 170, 17 (Fla.App.2012) (“the plaintiff must prove that it had standing to foreclose when the complaint was filed”); see also Burley v. Douglas, 26 So.3d 1013, 1019(Miss.2009), quotingLujan v. Defenders of Wildlife, 504 U.S. 555, 571, 112 S.Ct. 2130, 119 L.Ed.2d 351 (1992), fn. 5 (“ ‘standing is to be determined as of the commencement of suit’ ”);
In re 2007 Administration of Appropriations of Water of the Niobrara, 278 Neb. 137, 145, 768 N.W.2d 420 (2009) (“only a party that has standing may invoke the jurisdiction of a court or tribunal. And the junior appropriators did not lose standing if they possessed it under the facts existing when they commenced the litigation” [footnote omitted]).

PREVIOUS Ohio circuit court decisions:

{¶34} Thus the Third and the Ninth Circuits have rejected the notion that Fed. R. Civ. P. 17(a), on which Civ.R. 17(A) is based, allows a party with no personal stake in a controversy to file a claim on behalf of a third party, obtain the cause of action by assignment, and then have the assignment relate back to commencement of the action {and} “Rule 17(a) does not apply to a situation where a party with no cause of action files a lawsuit to toll the statute of limitations and later obtains a cause of action through assignment. Rule 17(a) is the codification of the salutary principle that an action should not be forfeited because an honest mistake; it is not a provision to be distorted by parties to circumvent the limitations period.
{¶37} Other courts have also determined that plaintiff cannot rely on procedural rules similar to Civ.R. 17(A) to cure a lack of standing at the commencement of litigation. Davis v. Yageo Corp., 481 F.3d 661, 678 (9th Cir.2007)
{¶38}We agree with the {above} reasoning and analysis presented in these cases. Standing is required to invoke the jurisdiction of the common pleas court. Pursuant to Civ.R. 82, the Rules of Civil Procedure do not extend the jurisdiction of the courts of this state, and a common pleas court cannot substitute a real party in interest for another party if no party with standing has invoked its jurisdiction in the first instance

JUDGEMENT REVERSED AND CASE DISMISSED
Andrew M. Engel, for appellants.
Bruce M. Broyles, urging reversal for amici curiae Homeowners of the State of Ohio and Ohiofraudclosure.blogspot.com


Posted by John MacHaffie at 5:04 PM 0 comments

2 Re: Foreclosure --- Update on fraud-closure on Tue Nov 06, 2012 3:34 am

MartyM

avatar
Gotta love it when the Court finally does something they are supposed to do. There's still a lot more of them (Courts/Judges) that need to get with the 'Program' and be held accountable to uphold their Oath of Office... Not the Oath to the 'BAR'.





'Tis better to be thought a fool,than to speak and remove all doubt.
     Love,Laughter & Prosperity...  :Santa 3: 

Back to top  Message [Page 1 of 1]

Permissions in this forum:
You cannot reply to topics in this forum